November 21, 2026 — The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services issued a Medicare Advantage proposal on November 20 that includes a new test of local competition and quality incentives. The proposed ADVaNCE MA model would run for ten years beginning in 2029 if finalized, with a pre-implementation period starting June 8, 2027.
What changed
CMS proposes mandatory participation in randomly selected states. A Diamond Ratings system would replace the existing Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings and Quality Bonus Payment system within the test, using a localized framework for comparing similar groups. The proposal does not replace Star Ratings nationwide today.
The model also includes shadow testing of an alternative risk-adjustment approach using existing claims, encounter and enrollment data. CMS describes this as a way to assess methodology, not an immediate switch to a new payment formula.
Why it matters — OX8 analysis
Quality incentives and risk adjustment influence insurers’ economics. A local comparison framework could change which operational improvements are most valuable to a plan, while alternative data methods could alter future payment-policy discussions. Neither direction establishes a revenue gain or loss for a particular insurer at this stage.
What to watch next
Watch the comment process, final rule, state-selection details and implementation guidance. Insurer disclosures about affected enrollment and preparation costs would help assess exposure. The key distinction is between CMS’s stated goals—competition, quality and lower spending—and results that would require evidence from the eventual test.
Featured image: original AI-generated conceptual illustration. Documents and rating symbols are fictional and do not depict actual plans, ratings or official CMS materials.


Leave a Reply